Jennifer Allan's post, "Good for you, let me know if you need anything." led me to think of Real Estate as an industry and the story of the emperor's new clothes.
While every industry has it's problems, I believe that the Real Estate industry has created some unique issues for itself that few wish to discuss openly. And probably because those in a position of power to change it are the same ones that financially benefit by the dysfunction.
One of the suprises for me as I learned more about the details of the Real Estate business in the last few years was how many real estate brokers are primarily in the business of renting desks and collecting a "piece of the action." Not all. But too many.
With all due respect, in some offices there are similarities to the mob. You have to be party of "the family." The law says so. You've got no where else to go but another "family." In time, you may can start your own "family."
And you are going to pay a piece of the action to the "family" on each deal, whether the "family" helps you out or not. In fact, you usually have to "prove" yourself to the "family" before you get much help. By then, if you survive, you may not need the help but that's cool. The "family" won't have to make the effort then either.
Why do they not help much in the beginning? They want to know if you "got what it takes" before they show much interest in helping. Survival of the fittest.
And there are turf wars over neighborhoods and customers, not only with other "families" but those in your own "family" too.
The old-school guys don't always see value of the young guns taking too much "action." Sometimes "killing a few off" preserves turf.
We deal with many agents and brokers from a different vantage point than agents, brokers and customers. It has been very revealing. In more cases than not, we found brokers that not only did little training and support but even "charged" a fee in some quasi-hidden way for any third-parties to have access to their agents for any reason, including educational.
I want to be clear. This is not all brokers. There are some that have figured out that they can increase their income from "pretty good" to "very good" by investing in their team and growing a great team. These people are a benefit to all those they interact with, including the public, their agents and even the economy.
But the majority we see don't bother building a real team because they make enough money with their own listings, buyers and renting desks to agents. It's enough money so why work any harder.
Attitudes are a reflection of leadership. And the leadership that could change this is the very same group that most benefits from it. Thus, they are not only incented to avoid change, they are incented to fight change. Thus, like George Orwell's Animal Farm, "All animals are created equal, but some animals are more equal than others."
Despite all this, there also remain Realtors surprised that the general public does not think highly of most the industry. This surprise to me is how many agents that are that out of touch with solid business concepts and/or consider all of the public as "lesser intelligence." And this serves no one, not even the agents.
I'm not sure there is an action point to this post. I don't see the model changing except to be gradually overwhelmed by a better informed public that will increasingly find ways around such dysfunction. The smart business people in this industry already know this and are making plans to be a part of these changes, for their benefit and to benefit the customers.
For the most part, the current business model rarely serves the customer best. However, history tells us bad business models and the market both self-correct over time. Tick. Tock.