In her blog, Janet Guilbalt wrote about "Inquiring Minds Want to Know: Why Do Realtors Trash Marketing from Mortgage Brokers?" Janet's post was in response to another interesting post by Jennifer Allan, "How Can a Lender Earn My Business?" In particular, Janet asked a great, really interesting question:
"Considering how important the financing part is to each precious transaction, why wouldn't Realtors be ACTIVELY SEEKING great mortgage lenders to add to their preferred list?"
In other words, regardless of your industry... Why wouldn't customers (and people that refer customers) not want to know about how great we are and how we can help them?
So what do most people do after they ask that? They decide to "help" others find them. They spend lots of time and money talking about themselves. They print brochures and fliers, buy TV and radio ads, they buy ads in programs, drop in on potential customers, and stand up in meetings and talk about... themselves.
Some do this well and are completely honest and are great! But most do this poorly... or do the pitch well but fail the delivery. We've all seen it and we are, honestly, jaded to the pitch. Even the people that do this approach ignore it from others.
Here are the problems with this "traditional" approach of fliers, keychains, pens, notepads, ball caps, lunches, brochures, etc.
1) We all hear the "how great we are" message literally thousands of times a day. Greatest service, greatest prices, greatest people, greatest response time, blah, blah, blah....
We've all learned to tune these out no matter how polite people are, no matter how professional the material is, no matter how important the value is. Admit it, you don't listen to this stuff all day long. Why would others?
2) Some people spend so much time and effort on their "how great I am" material, they fall in love with the material and the process.
Like raising a child or a pet. Time and money spent making it all perfect and important. And once this material is "loved", it becomes incumbent on the "parent" to love it, protect it and defend it from those that fail to see how important it is.
With all due respect, it is now virtually impossible for these folks to consider there are other approaches, "so 'gosh darn it' I'm going to fight to show I'm right!" (And maybe you are right... in that case, stay the course, for your are the great exception and should value that!)
3) It is not remarkable. Out of billions of marketing pieces and approaches, only the tiniest percentage become noticed to the point we literally talk about them.
Is "one-in-a-billion" the odds we want to invest money in? Surprisingly yes as people invest in this every day, thousands of times, even if it is just a few dollars at a time.
4) People forget to think about the customer's view (or the view of the partner we seek) BEFORE they have a relationship with you. Most make the mistake of thinking about how great the customer will see us once "they get to know us" through all the efforts we are making.
Why do potential customers want to meet you? Because you're great? Sure you are. But your customer (or potential partner) heard that message AAAALLL DAY LONG long and honestly, they don't have time to figure out who is great and who just has great material.
5) The customer (or partner) you want is likely doing well without you. At least the great ones, the ones you really want, are doing great. That is why you want them, right?
So you are asking to be added to their team with a nice speech or useful pieces of information on a flier? The great customers (and partners) are buried in this stuff. They don't have time to sort this out and, honestly, don't have to sort it out.
So what are we to do? BE great.
You see, many of the great customers and partner you seek are watching what others do. They are ACTIVELY SEEKING to grow their network of succes. Not all watch, but enough. The great customers and partners typically surround themselves with great folks. And they find those great folks by actively watching and remembering and by listening to those they deeply trust. Marketing material will almost NEVER interest these people.
They are "Actively Seeking"... not "Asking to be Sold."
Think sports for instance... do you find the best players by hearing about them or reading stats in the newspapers? That does not reflect how well they play with others, how their current team may limit them or how their current team may make them look better than they are.
You find the best by watching them in action. From that perspective you can see the big picture and how the real players perform under pressure of "game time."
Doris Phillips, the president of RealSource, worked for years as a successful title rep and marketing director. She says that at the time, she did all the things everyone else does, did them well and got business.
However, Doris said that since that time, she has gone back to her former employer and apologized for all the money she wasted on flyers, gas, lunches and time "doing what everyone else was doing." She says she learned that it may have gotten orders but it was the extra service that got the relationships.
In other words, success was about BEING great.
Related posts that may be of interest:
Does your marketing material FAIL... and you don't know it?
Forget Your Logo and Tag Line (because everyone else will)... What is Your Brand?

Glenn: What I have found work best is working very diligently on making personal referrals happen. No advertising can possible carry as much weight or credibility as being personally referred to you... or to me. I admit this cannot be done overnight, nor by the thousands as in a mail-out... but once it finally starts to work... it can turn to gold. Take care...
Glenn, I believe in this 100%. All marketing materials I receive go straight to the trash. If something catches my eye like a new program, it only makes me contact my lender.
Paul McFadden Mortgage Loan Originator Bellevue Washington Home Loans (The Legacy Group) Paul, great point. We do believe there is a place for informative material, but as a "leave behind" (when appropriate) after a meeting. And we have things that are specific to the audience, not just a general one-size-fits-all flier. Really something of a recap of what we can do to add value.
If we were referred by someone trusted and the meeting has gone well, the other party will even commonly ask for this type of information.
This material is never expected to get us a meeting or an order. And yes, it does need to look as profesional as everything else we do.
Great point! G
Glenn, I have found that clients & customers that seek me out are already predisposed to want my service and trust me through their on methods of investigation. Many times these are referrals, but others who have come to me were as a result of a bad experience with another firms saying how great they were and failing to deliver on the promise of greatness. I say to these other firms..thank you, and don't toot your horn so loud if it's out of tune.
Glenn - Amen!!! I couldn't have said it better (as much as I tried with Janet and Jennifer). I absolutely agree with you 100% about how our success is all about being great at what we do. Marketing materials only tell a small fraction of who we are and what we do and if they get trashed by Realtors (which I discovered very early in my career and haven't marketed Realtors since) then it was all for nothing.
The best way for a professional partner to find out who you are and how you operate is to have them watch you work. The second best way is to have someone they know, trust and respect refer you to them because that person that referred you has already seen you work.
But in order for that to happen, you need to first be good at what you do so quit worrying about why Realtors aren't responding to your marketing marterials and start spending that time, energy and money becoming really good at what you do. If you do that, hopefully, you will become better at what you do and then it will just be a matter of time before people start recognizing you for your work and not your marketing materials.
Glenn, it is not about US but about THEM! Our example and knowledge help THEM.
Fort Worth Real Estate - - - Karen Anne Stone (RE/MAX Trinity) Karen, you are right, the approach you found works is ultimately the most successful but also requires patience and persistance. Excellent points! G
Mark Organek - Tempe Gilbert Mesa Chandler REALTOR (RE/MAX Alliance) Mark, great point for others... your great marketing material may just inspire your potential customer to suggest business to someone they already trust. I've seen that. Great Point!! G
Steve Loynd, Alpine Lakes Real Estate Inc., Loon Mt, NH. "don't toot your horn so loud if it's out of tune.".... Love it, just love it! Great stuff! G
Glenn - Bravo! I'm bookmarking this because I want to include in the book I'm working on... cool with you? (with proper credit o'course)
Jennifer Allan, Author of Sell with Soul (Sell with Soul) Hi Jennifer, yes please use this in your book as you suggested. Very honored you are interested! Thanks! G
Donne Knudsen (Pacific Financial Mortgage) Donne, well said and well summarized! Good suggestion that lenders should spend less time on marketing material and more time on service. Sweet. G